The advent of costs budgeting on 1 April 2013 created uncertainty with regard to the relationship between budgeted costs and the detailed assessment of those costs. On 24 April 2017 Mrs Justice Carr gave her decision in Merrix v Heart of England NHS Foundation Trust which addressed the degree to which an approved budget could be departed from on assessment.
On the face of it CPR 3.18 specifies that an approved budget cannot be departed from without good reason. The judge upheld this approach. Of interest to practitioners is her decision that there should not normally be a an upwards or downwards departure from the budgeted costs. If followed to its logical conclusion this would mean that detailed assessments would only concern the incurred costs which are not considered by the court at the budgeting hearing.
What is less clear is the role the indemnity principle plays when costs at the conclusion of matter are lower than the budgeted costs.
