Recovery of non-solicitor’s costs

Octoesse LLP v Trak Special Projects Ltd [2016] EWHC 3180 (TCC) concerned a construction dispute which went to adjudication.  The defendant had instructed a claims consultant that considered the evidence, prepared a Defence and a witness statement, briefed counsel, liaised with and attended court.  The claimant resisted paying the costs of the consultant on the basis the defendant was in person and the claims firm neither did the work of the litigant in person nor was a disbursement.

Mrs Justice Jefford held that the work was specialist and there were areas of work which would have overlapped with a solicitor’s work, had one been instructed.  She held that it was likely a solicitor would have sought assistance from a claims consultant in any event and it was not unusual for claims consultants to represent parties in an adjudication.  As a result she held that the claims consultants’ fees fell within the meaning of disbursements in CPR 46.5(3)(a) and therefore could be recovered.